Posted by manuel on May 9th, 2009
Windows 7 RC 1 build 7100 review
I admit it, I’m still working with good old Windows XP. Like most friends I know. I didn’t switch to Vista for various reasons,… mainly the incompatibility with drivers and hardware (even brand new hardware I bought in 2009!) and some smaller bugs that didn’t get solved, mainly in the video card department.
I was pleasantly surprised to see the Windows 7 beta get better reviews and decided to pick up the free Release Candidate 1 May 2009 from the MS site.
It’s always nice to know who writes a review. I don’t like reading a game review for the Nintendo Wii, written by a total Playstation fanboy.
So let me start by telling a bit about my tester profile:
- I was a test engineer for a few years, mainly on networking products from a large manufacturer, I try Linux now and then but don’t like the time you’ll have to put into that OS before you can actually work with it the way you like it, I don’t like Apple because of the the fanciness and the totally noob-like OS (no offense but the only ppl I know working day-to-day with Macintosh are either trendy teens with freaky haircuts and medical staff).
Am I a microsoft fanboy? No,… I didn’t like Vista one bit, and I’m still working with XP while waiting for MS to come up with something that is really up to the task of today’s techworld,… which means I don’t like them either, but if I have to choose between and unworkably time-consuming OS (linux) and a trendy fad with dodgy hardware (Apple) or my own Custom PC with Microsoft OS then I clealy choose the latter.
Not that I like it, but it at least allows me to work for 4 years with the same hardware without failing and lets me install something without compiling days in a row or learning 120 commands by heart just to get a simple program to work properly.
The installation:
Windows 7 was installed in a very straightforward way, it’s easy and fast to get this thing running.
Only disadvantage on the RC1 version was that it started to scan my external hard drives before it was even installed… this took about 30 minutes in my first tryout setup process (after re-doing the install without these drives it only took 15 mins for the whole process).
The first impression you get with Windows 7 is that it’s fast. It boots fast, the menus and processess are sleek, everything seems to run just better and more smooth than XP.
The good:
The best improvement in Windows 7 is definately the Windows Explorer re-designs. Finally, after 10 years of using Total Commander, I could copy and paste whole directories without having to have the annoying ‘this file already exists’ message, after which the user could go on a hunt for the missing files and already copied files. Those days are over,… it took them 12 bloody long years to fix this and get some decent ‘replace file or skip’ option in place.
Now, if we wait another 10 years I’m sure they’ll introduce some kind of queuing function so I can ditch Total Commander (made in 1998) altogether for large copy tasks!! Please Microsoft, add this functionality because it’s a damn shame a freeware tool from the early nineties (remember, the time we watched Beavis and Butthead?) still beats your top notch OS in copying a file from one disc to another. It’s getting embarrassing.
MS seems to have no clue that in these times, there are people actually copying 200 GB to 2 TB a day in files. Copying with Windows Explorer is like drinking a barrel of beer with a straw.
It’s just not up to the task.
Let’s say Windows 7 Explorer is a huge step in the right direction, nothing more, nothing less, but certainly not perfect yet as a file manager (not by a long shot).
Second big improvement is the Home Network system, it finally works fine (on Vista it was nothing more that a good idea). The workgroup can still be used too, but the homegroup really works well.
So you can for example share and stream your fiels over the homegroup, without spending hours and hours fiddling with rights management and firewall settings. For example: with Vista I never could stream a video to my Xbox360, it connected, but couldn’t play, no matter what I tried.
The bad.
Windows 7 RC1 has it’s disadvantages of course.
Make no mistake, compared to Vista it’s a oasis of good programming. But even then, there are some nasty things awaiting you in this OS.
To not be labelled as a total nitpicker, I’ll only stick to the three main annoyance I’ve encountered on Windows 7. Also, this will alow us some breathing room to accept this new version, instead of bashing it from day 1 like what happened with Vista.
Annoyance 1:
Windows 7 has still the nasty Black & White bug. When you use an older TV with a SCART cable as second screen (to watch movies etc…) then you’ll be stuck with B&W in most cases. On XP this worked fine with the same ‘old’ hardware, but on both W7 and Vista this was not the case.
It never got solved, and believe me, I’ve tried every trick in the book to make this work, including swithing the TV on and off after trying each individual dual screen setting for PAL.
This is a total mood killer, we’re in 2009 and I would expect COLOR on a second screen, certainly when XP does it without problem.
Annoyance 2:
When you use Windows 7 in a home network (DSL router or some hubs) you’ll see some very very weird stuff happen on the Network front.
I have 3 interfaces: 2 Ethernet and one wireless built-in. I disabled one Eth and the Wi-fi (built-in crap) to just connect to my broadband router (Netgear).
The weird thing is that windows 7 seems to add an extra 0.0.0.0 gateway at random on top of my real gateway…
Cetainly when you reboot or come back from ’sleep’ mode this causes some headaches. (It’s easily solved by disabling the interface and enabling it again AFTER you deleted the extra 0 route with route delete in an Admin command line with elevation) eh… this is something A LOT of end users will have problems with.
I did some research and the whole ethernet dhcp part in Windows 7 is ‘dodgy’ to put it mildly. The DHCP metrics (for assigning priorities for the interface) is messed up. When I put my eht1 interface on metric 2 to let it have priority over the extra route that was added by Windows, the extra route AND my metric changed from 2 to 14 !
I don’t know what’s going on but DHCP will be an issue soon on Windows 7. I even wonder if anyone in Redmond (or wherever they test it these days) has even tried it on a simulated home network.
Annoyance 3:
I have 4 internal hard drives and 2 extrernal, they all work fin under XP, but Windows 7 seems to put some of these drives into sleep mode after a couple of minutes. I found no way to disable this.
The annoying thing is that the ‘data’ drive I used for all my picture and music is put to sleep at random. So when I want to play a file or open a picture, it takes ofter 10 seconds or longer for W7 to ‘find’ the drive.
This is totally a bummer when you make your desktop picture switch every hour or so. The system just HALTS completel (while gaming, chatting, or opening a programm usually:) to search for the picture somewhere on an idle disc.
After 5 to second the mouse starts moving again, your music starts playing again and THEN the picture appears.
The worst part is, after some time, the Windows 7 Os just gives up waking up the disc and jut DELETES it from the overview in explored. Just like it never existed. A reboot is required to wake W7 up again after that.
Imagine playing a game and when you’re done, you open one of your discs and it’s gone!
Like I said, I only list 3 points here, but I have a whole list, however the three mentionned items are really bugging me.
For now I’ll stick with Windows XP. As far as I’m concerned this is the best operating system MS ever released (since SP2).
Conclusion fro now; (8 may 2009)
While windows 7 shows some nice potential, the real big bugs still make it impossible to make this my main OS.
Review | No Comments »